In brief
- Individuals have a fundamental right to access their personal data, but AI is fuelling concerns about the growing volume and length of data subject access requests (DSARs).
- The Information Commission's Office has issued guidance on how organisations can respond efficiently and effectively to such requests.
- AI-drafted DSARs can be lengthy and complex, but using AI is not, in itself, a reason to refuse a request.
- Cut through the noise: read the request carefully to understand what personal data the individual is actually asking for.
- Where there are reasonable doubts about the requester’s identity, take proportionate steps to verify it before disclosing personal data.
Introduction
We know that organisations are increasingly seeing more data subject access requests (DSARs) drafted using generative AI. These tools make it easier for individuals to put together detailed requests, but more words do not always mean greater clarity. For organisations receiving them, lengthy explanations and legal jargon can make it harder to work out what the individual is looking for.
How to recognise an AI-drafted DSAR
Some features may suggest that a DSAR was drafted using AI, although none is conclusive on its own:
- They can be lengthy: AI-drafted DSARs may run to several pages, sometimes even tens of pages.
- They can be wordy: Legal jargon and lengthy explanations can make an otherwise straightforward request seem more complicated than it is.
- They can be list-heavy: Multiple headings, lists and sub-lists may reflect the way generative AI tools organise information.
- They can include “hallucinations”: References to legislation or legal requirements may sound convincing but be inaccurate.
These features can make a DSAR more time-consuming to read and harder to interpret.
Managing AI-drafted DSARs
The Information Commission’s Office (ICO) has published guidance on managing DSARs drafted using generative AI. The main takeaway is straightforward: using AI to draft a DSAR should not change how a request should be handled. An individual’s right of access under Article 15 UK GDPR does not depend on how they draft their request. This means that the fact that a DSAR has been created using AI is not, in itself, a reason to refuse it or to treat it as manifestly excessive or manifestly unfounded.
Always start by reading the request carefully. Is the individual asking for their personal data and, if so, what are they asking for? A long list of legal references, whether real or "hallucinated", should not distract from those basic questions.
Where the request is unclear or broad in scope, it is perfectly reasonable to ask the data subject to clarify what they mean to help you understand what they are looking for. In doing so, you should be specific about which parts need clarification and always use plain English. For example, it may help to ask whether they are interested in a particular time period, interaction, or type of personal data.
Identity checks also matter. There is a risk that someone could use generative AI and false identification to try to obtain another person’s personal data. If there are reasonable doubts about the requester’s identity, always take proportionate steps to verify it before disclosing personal data. This is particularly important if your organisation handles special category data, such as health information. If you suspect an identity document is false, consider contacting the individual through a separate, trusted channel, where possible, to confirm that they made the request.
In short, the focus should be on the content of the request, not the tool used to write it. The length or style of a DSAR may make it harder to read, but the starting point remains the same: is the data subject asking for their personal data? If the answer is yes, treat it as you would any other DSAR.
How we can help
Our Data team has published a Practical Guide to Data Subject Access Requests to support organisations handling DSARs internally. We also work with organisations to handle DSARs compliantly, rapidly and cost-effectively. Please do get in touch if you would like support with a particular request or your wider DSAR process.