Mishcon de Reya has successfully represented Standard Gas in resisting an attempt to dismiss its claim for £1 million in unpaid financing. The High Court’s decision keeps open the company’s bid to secure the promised funding, rather than being limited to a claim for damages.
The dispute concerns an agreement under which shareholder Andrew Goodwin committed to advance £1.5 million. He paid the first instalment, but the remaining £1 million was not advanced. Mr Goodwin sought to have the claim dismissed without a trial, relying on a longstanding legal rule restricting borrowers’ ability to make a claim in debt or specific performance against a lender who has failed to advance promised funds.
The agreement had unusual features. In return for the advances, Standard Gas agreed to suspend claims held within its group worth at least £2.1 million against the contractor building its pyrolysis plant, a company over which Mr Goodwin has significant control. Repayment was interest-free (unless there was an event of default) and contingent on the plant passing its site acceptance tests and a new fundraising of at least £5 million. In certain circumstances, Standard Gas could discharge its obligations by assigning the contractor claims to Mr Goodwin instead of repaying the money.
The Court recognised that this was not a straightforward commercial loan. It found that Standard Gas had a real prospect of showing that the package of rights could not readily be replaced in the market, and that subsequent fundraising did not replicate the benefits of the original arrangement.
The Court rejected the application to dismiss the claim and allowed Standard Gas to amend its case to claim the £1 million as an agreed sum or by way of specific performance. This preserves the company’s opportunity to seek the benefit of its agreed bargain at trial.
The judgment examines the scope of the century-old ‘No Debt Claim Rule’, an area of law that has received "remarkably little judicial scrutiny" but "fairly widespread extra-judicial criticism". The judgment indicates that it is at least arguable that the rule is not an absolute bar, and that a lender may, in exceptional circumstances be compelled to advance funds, for example where the obligation forms part of a broader bargain, or where damages would not be adequate.
The decision is relevant to lenders, borrowers and investors in shareholder funding, project finance and hybrid arrangements, where financing sits alongside the settlement or suspension of disputes, or other non-financial terms.
Mr Goodwin has sought permission to appeal. Subject to the outcome of that application, the substantive questions now fall to be decided at trial.
Oliver Felton and Annabel Getley represented Standard Gas, and instructed Cleon Catsambis of 3 Verulam Buildings. Judgment was handed down on 11 November 2026.